YES Bank AT1 Bond Dispute: ₹8,415 Crore Battle Returns to Supreme Court
The legal dispute over YES Bank Additional Tier 1 bonds worth ₹8,415 crore has entered another important phase. The Reserve Bank of India and YES Bank have both approached the Supreme Court seeking a review of its judgment that overturned the 2020 write off of these bonds. Bondholders are meanwhile demanding implementation of the ruling and restoration of their investments.
The dispute concerns two AT1 bond issuances made by YES Bank. The first was worth ₹3,000 crore, issued in December 2016 with a coupon rate of 9.5%. The second was worth ₹5,415 crore, issued in October 2017 with a coupon rate of 9%. Together, the two issuances account for ₹8,415 crore.
These instruments were written off in March 2020 when YES Bank was facing a severe financial crisis involving rising bad loans, governance concerns and a deterioration in its financial position. The Reserve Bank of India initiated a reconstruction process to stabilise the lender and bring in new capital.
The Central Government imposed a moratorium on YES Bank on March 5, 2020. The RBI superseded the bank board and appointed an administrator as part of the rescue process.
The RBI draft reconstruction scheme initially proposed permanently writing down the AT1 bonds. However, this provision was removed from the final reconstruction scheme notified by the Central Government on March 13, 2020.
Despite the removal of the provision from the final scheme, the administrator wrote down the entire ₹8,415 crore of AT1 bonds on March 14, 2020. Bondholders challenged the decision, arguing that the administrator did not have the authority to take this action under the final reconstruction scheme.
The Bombay High Court ruled in January 2023 that the write off was invalid. It held that the administrator could not exercise the power to write down the bonds after the reconstruction scheme had come into effect.
YES Bank, the RBI and the Union Government challenged the High Court decision before the Supreme Court. On October 15, 2026, the Supreme Court dismissed their appeals and upheld the decision setting aside the write off.
The Supreme Court found that the administrator had acted under an erroneous understanding of the powers available after the reconstruction scheme became effective. The final scheme did not contain a specific provision authorising the permanent write down of these bonds.
The judgment was significant because it meant the AT1 bond write off could not stand. It also addressed the payment obligations under the bond documents, including annual coupons in accordance with the applicable information memoranda.
The RBI has challenged the Supreme Court judgment through a review petition. It argues that the decision contains errors requiring reconsideration and that the loss absorbing purpose of AT1 bonds must be considered in the context of bank reconstruction and Basel III regulations.
The central bank has warned that restoring the bonds as liabilities could affect the capital position of YES Bank. According to the RBI, recognising the ₹8,415 crore liability could dilute the capital injected by SBI and other investors during the 2020 rescue, with possible consequences for existing depositors.
The RBI has also argued that AT1 instruments are specifically designed to absorb losses when a bank reaches severe financial stress. It believes that the judgment could weaken the effectiveness of these instruments in future bank rescue exercises.
YES Bank has independently filed its own review petition under Article 137 of the Constitution. The bank is seeking reconsideration of the October 15 judgment concerning the write down of its AT1 bonds.
The bondholders are taking separate legal steps to secure implementation of the Supreme Court ruling. Axis Trustee Services, acting on behalf of investors, filed a contempt petition on November 6, alleging that YES Bank had not provided a concrete roadmap for restoring the bonds.
The trustee has also been dealing with the issue of missed coupon payments. A coupon payment was due on October 19 on the ₹5,450 crore outstanding bond series, but investors have not received the expected payment. As of November 17, the trustee had not issued a separate default notice to the bank over this missed payment.
This delay has created uncertainty for investors who expected the Supreme Court ruling to lead to restoration and payment. The principal amount and unpaid interest remain matters requiring implementation and legal clarity rather than confirmed cash recovery.
On November 18, bondholders wrote to the RBI urging the regulator to prioritise investor protection and the implementation of the Supreme Court judgment. Their letter expressed concern that the regulator was seeking to challenge a ruling that had recognised the legal position of the bondholders.
The RBI and YES Bank review petitions have therefore complicated the timing of investor relief. The Supreme Court has not yet decided whether to reconsider its October judgment, and the review proceedings could affect when the bond restoration process moves forward.
AT1 bonds are a form of bank capital designed to absorb losses when a lender faces financial stress. They generally offer higher coupon rates than ordinary debt instruments, but investors face the risk of principal write down or conversion into equity when specified regulatory or contractual conditions are triggered.
These instruments form part of a bank capital framework under Basel III regulations. They help banks maintain capital buffers and are intended to provide an additional layer of protection during periods of financial difficulty. The YES Bank case raises questions about how contractual loss absorption provisions interact with the legal terms of a government approved reconstruction scheme.
The financial implications for YES Bank need careful assessment. If the bonds are restored as liabilities, the bank could face a substantial obligation involving principal and applicable coupon payments. However, the final accounting, capital treatment and payment arrangements will depend on the legal outcome and the implementation of the court ruling.
The dispute also matters for the wider banking industry because AT1 bonds are used by banks to strengthen regulatory capital. A legal interpretation that limits the circumstances in which these instruments can be written down could influence how future bank rescue plans are structured and how investors assess the risks of AT1 securities.
Investors should watch the Supreme Court proceedings, the review petitions filed by YES Bank and the RBI, the bondholders contempt petition, and any formal communication from Axis Trustee Services. The restoration of principal, treatment of unpaid coupons and impact on YES Bank capital will remain the most important unresolved issues.
The ₹8,415 crore dispute has moved beyond the original question of whether the 2020 write off was legally valid. It now involves the implementation of the Supreme Court judgment, the RBI position on bank capital protection and the rights of investors who held the bonds. Until the review proceedings and related enforcement steps are resolved, bondholders will continue to face uncertainty over the timing and extent of recovery.